Understanding Small Claims Court Records in New York

    Please enter a valid first name
    Please enter a valid last name

    NewYorkCourts.us is not a consumer reporting agency as defined by the FCRA and does not provide consumer reports. All searches conducted on NewYorkCourts.us are subject to the Terms of Service and Privacy Notice.

    In New York, the Small Claims court is set up to be informal and convenient for all individuals and small business owners to seek legal help without incurring excessive fees. Cases in the small claims court in New York are automatically scheduled in the court's evening calendars so people do not have to miss work to attend court sessions. The kinds of cases filed in a New York Small Claims Court include damage to personal property, real property, or a person, consumer protection, unpaid debts, failure to pay for services rendered, breach of lease or contract, loss of property, and bounced or stopped checks.

    Small claims court records document civil monetary disputes involving smaller financial claims where the amount sought is limited to $10,000. Claims for over $10,000 cannot be brought before a New York City small claims court. Likewise, in city/county courts, the monetary limit is $5,000 and up to $3,000 in town courts. These records typically include a description of the claim, the amount in dispute, the relationship between the claimant/plaintiff and the defendant, and other details.

    Public Access and Privacy Rules for New York Small Claims Records

    Under the New York Freedom of Information Law (FOIL), small claims court records are public, and every person has a right to view, inspect, request and access records of New York Courts and there are no restrictions on how public records may be used once obtained. Although the law upholds freedom of information, it restricts public access to private and sensitive government records to strike a balance between openness and privacy and the safety of individuals.

    The New York FOIL does not give members of the outside right of access to confidential and private records or any such records where disclosure may result in unwarranted invasion of business or privacy, disclose the identity of sex crime victims, or law enforcement investigation records.

    Small claim records are public records and may be accessed by residents of New York. These records include the case name and number, filing date, claim amount, description of the claim, copies of contracts and written agreements, witness statements, case outcome, and judgment order.

    Interested persons may obtain copies of public small claims court records from the local Civil Court Clerk's Office in the county where the claim was filed. They can also inspect records in person or look up court records online at the County Courts website or the state civil court website. Anyone seeking confidential records must file a formal motion with the civil court under state law, as those records are not public records and are not accessible online.

    What You'll Find in a New York Small Claims Court Record

    Residents of New York can find the following information in small claims court records:

    • Names of the Parties: The names and date of birth of the plaintiff/claimant (the party bringing the action) and the defendant (the party being sued/responding to the claim).
    • Claim Amount: The exact amount of money the plaintiff is seeking in the lawsuit.
    • Description of the Claim: The reason why the plaintiff is suing, the amount being demanded, and the relationship or business between the parties.
    • Judgment Date: The date the court gives a final decision in the claim.
    • Case Outcome: The judgment given by the court in the claim in favor of the plaintiff or defendant, the amount awarded by the court, or dismissal of the case (and reason for dismissal).
    • Payment Order: The order made by the court stating that one party must pay the other party a stated sum of money by a due date.

    Small claim records in New York must seek money only; they do not include motions to fix, fulfill a promise, or vacate a property. They may include settlement summary documents where the parties use alternative dispute resolution mechanisms. While small claim records are merely facts, they may influence credit or loan applications and background checks by landlords.

    How to Search Small Claims Court Records in New York

    Researchers can search small claims court records online at the New York State eCourts WebCivil Local case information system. The system indexes updated and older civil case information records. It offers information on party name, case number, court location, case type, case status, appearance dates and time, attorney name, filing date, and hearing outcomes. Access to the website is free as there are no search fees.

    To use the eCourts website:

    1. Visit the official New York eCourts WebCivil Local page.
    2. Choose a search method (by index number, party name, attorney, or judge name).
    3. Enter the search criteria available.
    4. Review the available court documents, case status, and hearing outcomes.

    Online case records are summarized versions of official court records. In order to access official small claims court records, contact or visit the local Civil Courts in the county where the case is filed. Visitors can inspect records at the county clerk's office at no cost. Researchers who request photocopies or certified copies of small claims court records will be charged for that service.

    The table below lists the access methods to find small claim court records in New York, where to search, and the associated fees.

    Access Method

    Where to Search?

    Costs/Requirements

    Online Search

    New York State Unified Court System - eCourts WebCivil Local

    No search fees

    In-person

    County or City Civil Court Clerk's Office (Court Directory)
    • In-person inspection Free
    • Copying Fee: $0.56 per page, with a $1.50 minimum fee for copies of the document
    • Certification Fee: $6.00
    • Production of Court Record: $20.00

    Others (mail, e-mail requests)

    Mail and e-mail requests may be sent directly to the relevant court clerk's addresses.
    • Copying Fee: $0.56 per page, with a $1.50 minimum fee for copies of the document
    • Certification Fee: $6.00
    • Production of Court Record: $20.00

    How Long Small Claims Records Stay on File in New York

    The New York Records Retention and Disposition Schedule determines how long small claims records stay on file. Per the Schedule, records of all small claims case proceedings, including landlord and tenant, commercial claims, and arbitration, shall be retained for twenty-five years from the date of initiation, then destroyed.

    Can Small Claims Court Records Be Sealed or Removed in New York?

    It depends. In New York, there are no laws to delete or expunge criminal or civil records. A public record can only be sealed; however, sealing civil records differs from the process and eligibility for sealing a criminal record.

    Civil records, including small claim court records, cannot be sealed for mere reasons. Part 216.1 of the Uniform Rules for New York State Trial Courts states that a court cannot enter an order to seal a court record, whether in whole or in part, except where it finds "good cause" to do so, and shall specify the grounds or basis for its findings.

    Also, remember that under the New York Freedom of Information Law, certain records have been classified as exempt from public disclosure. Thus, if any information in a small claims court record falls under such a category in the New York FOIL, or the court determines that a case of mistaken identity, or sensitive personal information is good cause, the court may enter an order to seal the record in whole or in part.

    A civil case being dismissed by itself does not make it eligible for sealing under the law; dismissal may only be a criterion for eligibility to have a criminal court record sealed under New York State's Clean Slate Act.

    Why New York Small Claims Court Records Matter

    Small claims court records matter as they are instrumental in enforcing judgments against debtors who have defaulted on a payment order or other post-judgment court orders. It also establishes a history of a dispute between two parties that was either resolved or unresolved in case a future dispute arises between the same parties or a defaulting party and another party.

    It is also necessary to document small claims court records because a party who is unsatisfied with a lower court's judgment can decide to appeal to a higher court, and the record serves as evidence. Most importantly, small claims court records are part of public records; they promote transparency and accountability in the civil law system.

    Do You Need a Lawyer for a Small Claims Court in New York?

    It depends on the person and the complexity of the case. The Small Claims Court allows all parties to sue and respond to a suit without a lawyer. It is a simple, low-cost, and informal court where anyone can sue without a lawyer. Now, a claimant/plaintiff or defendant may choose to hire a lawyer if they feel the need to. However, this is not necessary. The court also encourages parties to attempt to settle out of court or try mediation.

    While hiring a lawyer is not necessary, having legal representation can be helpful in preparing the case, appeals, understanding what documents or evidence are necessary to build a stronger case, assisting in negotiation settlements, and providing general advice about the case.